Support Our Site

Yesterday afternoon the internet was buzzing with details of the launch of Microsoft Windows Phone 7 Series in Barcelona. Only it wasn’t really a launch, it was more a demonstration of a preview version of the platform. It’s predecessor was only launched last autumn, and this pretty well complete rewrite of the Microsoft mobile phone platform isn’t going to be available to buy until around the same time this year.

Whilst it certainly seems to have innovative features – a user interface that does things rather differently from the current favoured multiple pages of icon design that is almost ubiquitous, along with an XBox Live tie up to link your mobile and console gaming – it does seem a pretty brave move to show your rivals what you’ve got planned months and months before anything is going to be released. Even when you take into account that Microsoft are often much more open about showing preview releases of upcoming products than Apple for example, it still seems very early to be showing.

However, when you think about it, if Microsoft wants any part of the rapidly growing mobile applications market, it had to do something.

Microsoft, just like Nokia, Sony/Ericsson and all the rest were caught massively on the hop three years ago by the launch of the iPhone. Smart phones were very much of a niche market, and most regular consumers used a phone to make calls. It was possible to add applications onto smart phones, but again it wasn’t something that many people did.

Roll forward three years and the iPhone has really gone mainstream, it still surprises me how many people have them, and who they are. Many of them, even relatively non-technical are comfortable with the idea of adding applications, reading e-mail, browsing the web and playing games from a phone handset. On top of this Google has moved in on the market making waves with it’s Android operating system. Established players like Nokia have found their market share falling after years of failing to ignite the smart phone market.

Then we get to Microsoft.

They had a niche in corporate markets, and certainly I’d come across techies from time to time using (and more often than not cursing) their Windows Mobile handsets. The ability to program applications in the same languages as desktop applications certainly helped adoption. However they largely dropped the ball. Whilst they have carried on releasing updated versions of their platform they’ve largely been left behind, giving the impression – intentionally or not – that they weren’t interested, that they were happy to relinquish their market share to Apple and Google. In the corporate space Blackberry has grown, certainly in our company those users who are issued with a smart phone are issued with a Blackberry, and many of the executives ask for one by name. Any mobile applications would have to be developed for Blackberry, not Windows Mobile now, and Blackberry provide the tools to do that.

As I’ve said, the iPhone seems to have really gone mainstream, introducing a growing range of people to a smart phone, and the techie space seems to be being filled by Google Android. The iPhone is selling by the million, and producing billions of application downloads.

What Microsoft were showing looks interesting, and if they can sort out the reliability and stability problems that established wisdom say plagued previous versions it would be a good platform, but it would be a good platform if the phones were on the market now. Between now and release Apple, Google and the rest will certainly be releasing updated and new versions of their phones and software. The Microsoft gamble is that having seen the show yesterday, people will be willing to wait, and that come the autumn they will be willing to put aside the previous reputation for being buggy, put down their iPhones, Blackberry and Android phones, write off the money they’ve spent on apps for those platforms – or in the corporate environment infrastructure, and switch over to a Microsoft phone. I’m sure there will be a good few techies who will do so, but the average consumer or the corporate user? It remains to be seen.

Possibly Related Websites

News today that there is a new version of Google Maps for Mobile alongside there now being a Symbian native version it also includes a ‘My Location’ feature that triangulates an approximate location based on the cell towers the phone can communicate with. So away I go downloading it – runs great, aside from the ‘My Location’ feature which produces an error that my location is temporarily unavailable. Anybody managed to get it to work on an N73 running X-Series on 3?

Possibly Related Websites
iPod Touch Web Browsing

So having had an iPod Touch to play with for a couple of days, I thought I’d give my first impressions.

Firstly, being an Apple device, the integration between the iPod Touch and the Mac is great. Effectively all you have to do is plug the iPod Touch into the computer and you can sync music from iTunes and pictures from iPhoto straight down onto the device. Needless to say, in my situation where both databases are much larger than the capacity of the device you need to take some level of manual control, but compared to getting stuff onto the Nokia N770 it’s a lot more straightforward. By way of comparison, putting music onto the Nokia involved a bit of care with file formats – and also remembering that anything protected probably wouldn’t work, putting on pictures you’d have to manually ensure they were the right dimensions – with the iPod that is all automatic.

Once loaded onto the iPod the slick experience continues. You can browse through music either in familiar list form, or alternatively turning the device to a landscape orientation automatically activates cover flow mode where you can flip through albums via their album art. Pictures are similarly presented, again allowing you to flick through the images.

All of the interface operates through a touch-screen – in total the device has only two buttons, the ‘power’ button on the top, and a home button that always takes you back to the main menu. Unlike almost all similar devices there is no stylus – you operate the interface with your finger. Flicking through photographs or songs is all carried out by sliding your finger across the screen. Surprisingly there isn’t too much of a problem with finger marks on the screen either – although the metal casing shows them up, the screen is readable even after quite heavy use of the screen.

The other great feature of the interface is the momentum. When you flick, much as if you push an object in the real world, it carries on moving and slowly decelerates. If you are scrolling down a long list of tracks for example you can also catch the list by touching the screen, which brings the scrolling to an immediate halt. Comparing this to other interfaces where you’re repeatedly pressing an arrow key to scroll down, or that come to an immediate halt, it is much more intuitive, and even though I have over 2000 songs loaded onto it is still relatively quick to locate them.

The momentum in the interface also extends to the built in web browser, which in part goes towards making the iPod Touch far and away the best mobile browsing experience I have come across. The Nokia N770 may have the best screen (well at least until it failed), but the iPod more than makes up for it with the ease with which I can move around a web page and zoom in and out onto content. Hitting links accurately with a finger rather than a stylus takes some work, as does typing on the on-screen keyboard, but it is still streaks ahead of anything else.

Perhaps the only disappointment is the YouTube application. Whilst it does manage to make videos from YouTube look considerably better than they do on the web, it has one major flaw – when it is running it hogs the machine, and if the flow of data from the site stalls, so does the application. It doesn’t actually crash the iPod, but it does render it unresponsive until the data stream settles down again.

Looking at other things you can do with it, one of the big criticisms when compared to the iPhone was the lack of an e-mail application. Whilst you can add mail by copying the app over from an iPhone, you can do it without hacking the device using a site called Mail Coaster. This very simply provides an iPod Touch style web interface to whatever mail server you specify. It’s not the most feature rich application, but for a simple mail check it is fine. Google Reader is also among the sites that now also have an iPod Touch friendly user interface.

By far the most impressive thing about the whole device, especially having used Windows Mobile, Symbian and the Nokia N770 is how rock solid the whole device feels. That’s not to say there aren’t bugs – the aforementioned problem with the YouTube application for a start, and on one occasion it has inexplicably lost the wi-fi connection – but it has yet to properly crash, unlike the multitude of mobile devices I’ve owned from the other stables. It also doesn’t suffer from the annoying and inexplicable pauses that those suffer too, aside from the YouTube problems everything moves along at a nice responsive speed.

It may be being marketed purely as a music player, but alongside this Apple have converged enough with the features of the PDA that they’ve produced a pretty good stand-alone PDA too!

Possibly Related Websites

I blogged a couple of years ago about an article about Stephen Fry that appeared in Mac Format and about his addiction to the Mac platform stretching back twenty years.

Recently Stephen has started a blog and the topic of his first posting – Devices and Desires – which discusses another technological addiction, mobile devices and Smartphones. Not surprisingly he has an iPhone, but this looks at the competition, most of which he has tried.

Style wise this is a bit different from your usual technical article – very Stephen Fry (so it does have a couple of more adult comments) – but it is a great read, and pretty funny in places. Incidentally as an example of the quirkiness, the title of the article is taken from the General Confession in the Book of Common Prayer (“I have followed too much the devices and desires of my own heartâ€?)- not a common point of reference for a computer article, but somewhat appropriate!

Looking at his history, it seems he is a Psion 3 fan whereas I only came in when the Psion 5 was launched. He’s tried Palm devices, but is very frustrated with the way they seem to regularly try to commit corporate suicide. He is particularly damning about the Palm Foleo, a mobile device even he did not want.

As an aside he also mentioned Markspace Missing Sync as a good way to synchronise a PocketPC with a Mac – not surprisingly after my nightmare with the product I can’t agree. Despite it’s numerous updates over recent months, I’m still not sure I actually trust it not to scramble my diary!

According to the article, he has tried a number of Symbian smartphones, and has some harsh words for Sony Ericsson:

What a crushing, lowering, fury-inducing disappointment. Just how dumb are the software engineers, designers and marketeers at Sony E?

On the other hand, he seems to quite like the latest Nokia offerings.

Moving on to the iPhone, he has many of the same criticisms as other techies and industry commentators – but again like quite a few in the US he is using the phone anyway.

What is quite impressive is that for a blog with only one article, Stephen Fry has so far had 140 comments – hopefully that will persuade him to write more as I for one will certainly be reading.

Possibly Related Websites

A little story here for anybody who has ever struggled with the T9 predictive text facility on their mobile phone. Whereas some people struggle with it, an Italian commuter has, over the course of seventeen weeks of commuting used his Nokia 6630 to write a 384 page novel! The result of his labours is now available on Lulu.com – sadly only in Italian.

Possibly Related Websites

It is mere days since the Apple iPhone hit the streets in the States, and the simmering holy war has well and truly burst into life, particularly with avid Nokia N95 fans evangelising their platform.

Perhaps one of the most interesting places to observe the current skirmishes is over on Scobleizer, the reason being that Robert Scoble has been using and enjoying an N95, but having queued with his son to get an iPhone, and then compared the two phones, is coming down in favour of the Apple.

Check out the reaction to this post where he begins:

Let’s just stop here. The iPhone is superior in almost every way to the Nokia N95. The battery life is better. The contact management is better. The Web browser is better. The photo taking experience is better. The screen is better. The wireless management is better.

After that, he does then take a pot-shot back at the Nokia fans.

However, what is happening is what has happened with the iPod before, the fans of other smartphones are quoting feature lists – highlighting that there are a number of key missing features with the iPhone – things like a GPS, 3G support and so on. The thing is though, that as with the iPod the purchasers (of which there have been over 0.5 million in the first weekend alone) are going for looks and basic usability over the feature list.

The iPhone scores highly by being cool, and by doing a few things and doing them well. True the Nokia N95 has a better camera, but the software that drives the camera, which is the same as on my Nokia N73 is lousy – certainly there is no chance of taking a decent picture quickly as you have to fiddle with all the settings every time you open the camera as they always reset to default. Based on comments around the internet, as expected the iPhone is scoring points in usability, an area where the current crop of smartphones often fall down. However much the fans of the other phones quote feature lists, whatever toys a phone has, basic usability is where it matters – I know numerous people who have never worked out how to use even the basic features of their phone – even changing a ringtone.

As to whether I’ll get one, without 3G or the ability to take a decent picture, I’m not keen. Get that sorted out and maybe I’ll take a look – of course it could all go out the window when I eventually get to play with one. Whatever happens though, I’m hopeful that having Apple at the party will give the competition a good kick in improving the usability on their models too.

MyStrands in the iPhone and in the N95 originally uploaded by MyStrands.

Possibly Related Websites

There are a couple of significant computing anniversaries this year. Firstly, it is twenty years since version 1.0 of Powerpoint was released – initially only for the Apple Mac, the PC version came along a few years later once Microsoft bought out the original company. Presentation Zen not surprisingly has an article on the anniversary linking off to a Wall Street Journal interview with the original developers who ponder what their creation has become and the effects it has had on business. This quote from Robert Gaskins is particularly telling:

“A lot of people in business have given up writing the documents. They just write the presentations, which are summaries without the detail, without the backup. A lot of people don’t like the intellectual rigour of actually doing the work.”

The other anniversary is that this week marks ten years since the Psion 5 was launched. The Register have done a great article telling the story of Psion and the people involved from the birth of the Psion 5 until the present day. What is amazing is how many ex-Psion staff have gone on to be part of market leading companies working on gadgets that Psion weren’t able to produce themselves. There is also a good deal of discussion as to the reasons that Psion ultimately withdrew from market, which in part seems to be blamed on existing customers who stuck with their Psion 3′s. Interestingly although Psion may be gone from the the PDA market, it is interesting to note that their belief in their operating system, Symbian was well founded. It does sort of leave you wondering how things might have been different if Psion had the finances to produce all the gadgets they had ideas for.

Possibly Related Websites

So this afternoon I let the Nokia Update Service update the firmware on my N73 to 3.0638.0.0.1. The update process has all sorts of dire warnings, including telling you several times that you should back up the phone memory, as the update will clear out the contents. It then suggests using the ‘Backup to Memory Card’ option in the memory tool. So I dutifully went and made the backup, and then let the upgrade run through. The phone restarted, and I restored the backup – but although all the data in the core applications came back, a number of the additional applications I’d loaded onto the phone had gone. A quick look at what had survived, and it seems that anything Java based had been restored, but all the S60 native applications had vanished. It’s not too much of a problem to add them on again, just a bit tedious… :(

Possibly Related Websites

So after a pretty long wait, earlier this week our new phones were finally enabled by 3. It took their IT department several attempts to get it all working – including one slightly bizarre call where I was speaking to Simon on one mobile, whilst testing the other, and he was on the other end talking to one of the IT staff on another phone. Ultimately, they just came on. I had a MSN messenger message from Simon saying that the IT department had tried something else, but they thought it was unlikely to work – but it did.

Over the past few days I have been installing software onto the phone, and trying out various of the features of both the Nokia N73 and the service, including installing Opera Mini and Google Maps Mobile – both of which run well and look great on the phone. Also, in a move that probably will please Andy Tiller who spent a good deal of time trying to help me last year, I have got Shozu installed onto the new phone. Unlike with the K750 it went on without a hitch, and I was impressed with how easy it was to upload a picture. You can see my Shozu uploaded pictures on Flickr. (Nothing particularly awe inspiring as yet though…)

Although I said that I was going to leave setting up the Slingbox for our new house, since after the events of last weekend there will be no new house, I had to find a way to get the Slingbox somewhere suitable, but connected to the network. In terms of the best place, this had to be downstairs on top of our Sky+ box, as this isn’t in a cabinet, and so shouldn’t suffer from the heating problems I had when I previously tried out the box. However that is about as far from our internet connection as you can get in the house, and in a location that although a wireless link would probably work, the performance would be pretty poor. Running a normal network cable is not really an option either, so instead I turned to Power Line Communication, specifically a pair of HomePlug Turbo units from eConnect.

eConnect HomePlug Turbo

I have to say that these are probably the first device I’ve come across that really deserves the title plug-n-play, I literally plugged one unit into a socket upstairs, the other in downstairs, hooked the cable up to our router and the Slingbox popped up on the network, no configuration required at all. Speed wise it is not quite up to the speed of a direct network connecting, but faster that I could get with a wireless connection, running at between 65Mbps and 75Mbps. Certainly for anyone looking to extend their network in a similar way it seems by far the most straightforward way to do it, and certainly beats messing around with wireless settings.

Initially I have set the Slingbox up as before, using it’s inbuilt terrestrial digital decoder. Later I may well set it up to use the Sky+ box as well.

Having got that all set up, and confirmed it was working using the desktop version of the SlingPlayer, I then moved on to try the mobile version supplied as part of the X-Series.

The first thing it did was to download the latest version of the software itself, and then it was just a question of entering the identifier code for our particular Slingbox. Unfortunately this is the one really tedious aspect of the whole set-up process, as the identifier is a very long hexadecimal identifier, which is a bit of pain to key in using a mobile phone keypad. Thankfully it only needs to be entered once, as the player stores the Slingbox in it’s built in directory.

Slingbox Mobile in Action

Unfortunately, the picture doesn’t do it justice, the picture quality is surprisingly good. The main issue, which could well be a routing issue between 3 and our current ISP, Zen Internet is that the data stream quite often stalls. Looking at the router, the data is still going out, it just seems to be getting delayed somewhere along the way to the phone. At some point I’ll try using a desktop version of the player on some other connections and check out the variations in quality and performance, and hopefully nail down where the stalling in the stream is coming from. It is not apparent when watching on the LAN, so I can only conclude that it is somewhere along the way across the Internet.

Anyway, despite the hiccups, it still is a really impressive feat. Whilst the mobile sized screen is not the best way to watch TV, the mere fact that it works as well as it does over a mobile connection is amazing.

Possibly Related Websites

So there I was on Saturday, fully expecting by this point to be able to write about my now activated X-Series phone, but come Monday morning, I was still getting the ‘your phone will be activated in 24 hours’ service message on both mine and Beth’s phone.

I’d already talked to Simon on Sunday about the time it was taking, so when I let him know that the phones were still not on, he chased it up. After talking to some colleagues he came back with the answer that both our phones, together with a whole batch of other sales (another six customers I believe) that went through at the same time had produced an error on registration. From what I can gather, although our phones and SIM cards are valid for the 3 network, the phone also has to be registered at the other end. As part of this process, the sales order number is validated, and for some reason the network systems are refusing to accept all the sales order numbers for our particular batch – so it’s not just us with the same problem. Currently their IT department appear to be trying to fix the problem to allow the phones to register – not the most salubrious start to our relationship with 3 – have to hope that X-Series is worth it!!!

Possibly Related Websites

As some of you may know, my brother works for 3, the 3G only mobile phone operator here in the UK.

Not surprisingly he has been trying for years to get myself and Beth to switch over to his companies network from our current operator O2 who I’ve been with since I got my first mobile phone back in the the days when it was known as Cellnet.

Well this week he finally succeeded.

The fundamental reason I haven’t switched over until now has been the attitude of 3 towards data usage. Although Beth uses her phone as a phone so-to-speak, my main usage is data. Indeed for the past few years I’ve been on a long retired low user with only about 30 minutes of free monthly calls – which I don’t use, and then a data bolt on. Through the phone I can access pretty well anything I like on the internet, including downloading my e-mail, any websites I want and so on.

Until recently, for a domestic mobile phone user the situation on 3 has been very different. The company operated their mobile internet service as a Walled Garden offering only approved websites, so I would be unable to use the phone to access my own e-mail or websites, and a lot else besides. However at the tail end of last year that all changed, with the launch of the X-Series offering. There are lots of bits and bobs in the package, including a version of Skype, and a version of Microsoft Messenger, but the key things that attracted me were that it was flat rate unlimited mobile internet usage, and in one package they were offering a Slingbox at almost half-price, complete with a client for the phone. Cost wise it is a £10 a month add-on to any of the regular tariffs, or £5 without the Slingbox. When you consider that this is around what I’m paying O2 for a 5Mb allowance, after which I get charged about £1 a Mb, you can see why the deal is so attractive. On top of that you obviously get a new handset – currently only the Nokia N73 is supported, but with other phones to come – and I was hooked.

So as Beth wasn’t left out (and so I had someone to video call) we also got a new deal for Beth, in her case she got an LG U830.

X- Series Hardware

Anyway, the postman turned up this morning with a couple of packages for us containing the new phones and the Slingbox which we spent the day playing around with and sorting out.

The Nokia N73 is one of the large range of Symbian based Smartphones. It is certainly clear when you take it out the box quite how far things have come since my previous dabbling with a Smartphone, with my Nokia 3650. The screen is a significant improvement, and higher resolution, and with one of the best cameras on a current phone – second only to the camera on the Sony Ericsson K800i it is definitely clear how far things have come.

Nokia N73 SE K750i Size Comparison

In terms of size and looks things have improved too – size wise it is not that much bigger than my current Sony Ericsson K750i – thickness is about the same, the main difference is in the length.

Anyway, since we have to wait twenty-four hours for the phone to be activated, I’ve only loaded my calendar and contacts onto the phone, and trying out some of the online toys will have to wait. Not that it mattered though, as I had the Slingbox to play with.

As you can see from the pictures, the Slingbox isn’t all that big either, but it definitely is powerful in what it can do. Essentially the box makes a connection between your TV reception, and your network, allowing you to watch TV anywhere that can access your network. As a result, not only does it allow you to watch TV on any computer in the house, but if you have remote access to your network, any computer in the world. The software that goes with the box is also clever enough to adapt based on the speed of the connection between your computer and the box.

Unlike a lot of audio/visual equipment, the Slingbox comes with everything you need, including all the different sorts of cables to connect to your TV and video equipment. Although the box can drive a Sky, or indeed a Sky+ box, it takes it over – so if the Slingbox is watching one channel, the TV can’t watch another. The real power is that the box also includes both an analogue, and a FreeView tuner. Now although we’re not in an official FreeView area currently, we will be when we eventually move. As a result I didn’t set the box up permanently, but instead had a play around. Beth probably wouldn’t have much liked it being left set up anyway – as the nearest aerial point to the broadband connection is in a different room on the other side of the house, for most of the day I had 15m of network cable trailed across the house!

Anyway, the Slingbox was remarkably easy to set up – with the wired connection and UPnP enabled on the router it really was plug in and play, even on a Mac.

I’m quite used to, even with equipment that is listed as Mac compatible, to find that it is a lot more difficult to set up without a PC, but that’s not the case with the Slingbox. Although still in beta, the Mac version of their client worked flawlessly, and took me through configuration of the box, including updating the firmware over the network, and configuring all the channels. I also found that despite not being in a FreeView area, the box managed a pretty large selection of the channels that are available, including all the major stations. The picture was okay too – at least until the wind started to blow the aerial on the roof around a bit later on. Certainly it was enough to try out the box, both across the wired network, and also from a laptop hooked up wirelessly.

The main criticism I have is that the box runs pretty hot – not quite as hot as our Sky and Sky+ boxes, but certainly enough that putting the Slingbox into the same enclosed TV stand that we have our upstairs Sky box in seemed to be asking for trouble. As a result of that, plus the current need to have a network cable trailed across the landing, I packed the box back up until I could sort out the networking, and find a better location for the box. Since I’ll have to do the same anyway when we move, I suspect that, unless there is some pressing need for the box (like a US trip where I need to bring some British TV along with me) it will be something to look forward to when we move into the new house.

If you want to find out more about the X-Series offering, take a look at the main website which lists all the key features, and has prices too. The offer is only available direct from 3, they’re not allowing it to be sold through any third party. There is also a great X-Series blog maintained by some of the people at 3, which includes a regular posting of the frequently asked questions about the service.

Possibly Related Websites

© 2010 Exigency In Specie Suffusion WordPress theme by Sayontan Sinha