Category Archives: Music

Posts on musical topics

Has Your Voice Broken Mr Archer?

Malcolm Archer Workshop

Tonight, myself and a number of other members of the Church Choir went along to an RSCM organised Choir Workshop at All Saints in Wokingham, led by Malcolm Archer, currently the Director of Music at St Pauls Cathedral in London, and having previously held the same post at Wells Cathedral in Somerset.

The subject of the workshop was his Requiem, a work that we are planning on doing in November at St James. So for two hours we had a whistle-stop tour of the whole work, looking briefly at each of the movements in turn. We also had a question and answer session, talking about his work at St Pauls.

One of the most surprising things was his singing. Now most choir trainers can sing most parts, however Malcolm is actually able to sing the soprano line better than a number of our junior choir – even managing a top A at one point! Somebody actually asked him what his ‘normal’ range is in the question and answer session. The answer is interesting in that his speaking voice is, like most men, a baritone. However he has problems actually singing in the baritone register. If he is singing, he usually sings alto, which is what he was asked to do when his voice broke, and he’s never changed. As a result he has been trained to sing in that register, so is able to manage the soprano part – a useful skill when training choirs.

After explaining this, he told us a funny story about a recent audition he conducted for a new chorister at St Pauls. The young boy came along, and when it came to the pitch test, where he plays a note on the piano, and the choirboy has to sing it, he couldn’t get the pitch. To give him another chance, Malcolm then tried singing notes, which the boy could manage. After the audition, the boy asked Malcolm whether his voice had broken yet – since he could sing all the soprano notes apparently at this point his assistants were desperately trying not to burst out laughing…

I have to say that it was definitely a worthwhile way to spend a couple of hours. It is very rare to get to work with one of the top people in Church music in such a comparatively ‘personal’ setting – it was effectively a combination of the choir from All Saints, and the choir from St James, plus one or two others. Usually when you get to work with a composer on one of his own works, it is as part of a massed choir, usually several hundred strong. Here he could spend time chatting, and signing copies for many of the people there, and could even spend time with the juniors giving them tips on how to achieve the top notes.

St James Welsh Supper

After our patriotic English supper near St Georges day last year, with Rev Richard having Welsh roots, this year it was decided to do a Welsh supper, held close to St Davids day.

Women of the Choir

So last night we all gathered up at the Parish Centre for a meal of Leek and Potato soup, followed by a Welsh stew, and then Bread and Butter pudding, with a mixed bag of entertainment including Rev Richard singing the Welsh National Anthem, John Dewhurst reading from Dylan Thomas, and as usual with a number of contributions from the choir.

It has to be said that there were some decidedly non-Welsh items on the running order – indeed some that we used at the English evening last year! However, the gentlemen of the choir contributed the finale, a male voice choir version of When I Survey the Wondrous Cross written by Emrys Jones. The first four verses are comparatively quiet, at least according to the music, however the final verse is marked double f, so with the full group of eight men in our choir is apparently pretty loud! Following on from that, the full choir did a new version of the well known Cwm Rhondda, with words to welcome John Edwards, our new assistant priest. When it was announced, Rev Richard started to look worried – as the past couple of concerts, he has been the subject of various items with new words – there was a definite look of relief when Andrew said that Rev Richard was being given a break this time, closely followed by “Hello John!â€?.

As before, the revised words for the item were written by Andrew Powell, one of the other basses, who spends a lot of time during the week on the road for work (not sure if that is a valid excuse…). However, he provided two items this time, the other involving Beth. Outside Beth, Julia, Andrew Powell and Andrew Bosely who played the piano, I think I was the only person who knew what was going on. Certainly Paul, Julia’s husband, based on his intro didn’t know what was going on, and apparently Andrew Powell had some awkward questions earlier in the day when his wife found a long black hair in their bathroom! Anyway, thanks to Andrew having brought his video camera along, you can enjoy Beth, Julia and Andrew performing a version of Three Little Maids from The Mikado by Gilbert and Sullivan. Dodgy camera-work by yours truly, comedy introduction by Paul…

How Live is Live?

We saw part of The Culture Show on BBC2 this week, which amongst other things included the launch of a campaign by the Musicians Union to provide an on-screen indication of whether a musical performance is mimed or live.

The campaign has been launched following an ICM poll that had found that 71% of the public would like some sort of indication. They then had different artists giving their opinion, Beverley Knight arguing for the indication, and Faye Tozer, former member of Steps arguing for the benefits of miming.

Perhaps the most interesting part of the item was the discussion with a Top of the Pops producer. Top of the Pops like other similar shows such as CD:UK have a mixture of people miming, people singing live to a backing track, and occasionally fully live performances. The item included some footage of live shows where the singer couldn’t hear the backing track, and some footage of Oasis who apparently have never sung live on Top of the Pops because it meant that they wouldn’t be able to drink before the performance! In the initial interview, the producer said that in a show with so many different acts in a short space of time, it was very complicated to have them all play live and be properly set up. He then justified it by saying that in his opinion people weren’t bothered too much by miming. What was interesting was his pretty surprised reaction when the interviewer quoted the results from the poll.

From a personal point of view, especially if I’m paying good money, I feel short changed if it isn’t live. To be frank if I wanted to hear a recording, I could go down to a record shop and get a CD! The same is true about TV shows. I haven’t watched Top of the Pops for years, however the one programme I do watch from time to time is Later with Jools Holland, which was noted on The Culture Show item as being about the only show on TV that is 100% live. What they do on Later is take advantage of the live medium to do special versions of songs, or to put interesting combinations of artists together. Indeed some of the older albums I listen to frequently are live recordings, CD’s such as “Way We Walk Vol.2â€? by Genesis which is a set of six live songs the majority of which run for between ten and twenty minutes. Another favourite is the live version of Sgt Peppers Lonely Hearts Club Band that Paul McCartney has on “Tripping the Live Fantasticâ€?. Here he combines the original song with the original reprise – which is in a different key – into one six minute performance by almost three minutes of guitar solo by both Paul and another guitarist, passing the solo back and forth across the stage, still one of my favourite performances of the song. So do I think that the liveness of a performance should be highlighted? Absolutely, whatever people may say about how miming gives bands the opportunity to put on more of a show, ultimately what I’m interested in is the music!

Rock School Mark 2

So tonight we had the first of the second series of Rock School, the series where Gene Simmons, of Kiss fame, tries to bring together a rock band out of a bunch of school kids. Whilst the previous series took a group of well spoken young people from Christ’s Hospital, a private school, this time it’s a group from a comprehensive school –Kirkley Community High School in Lowestoft, Suffolk.

It’s a pretty different environment, as Simmons realises as soon as he arrives, he pretty quickly comments on the difference in behaviour. Whilst I’m sure the students in the playground are acting up for the camera, it’s certainly true that a comprehensive class will be a very different experience. However a look at the schools most recent inspection report shows that perhaps the TV programme makers are playing up the differences a bit for effect.

However, there is a big difference in the young people with whom Gene is working. Whilst the young people selected at Christ’s Hospital could probably be expected to have good career prospects, and look forward to that, primarily picked because they are musical, the situation in Lowestoft is very different. For many in the selected group see no real future for themselves, seeing Lowestoft as a dead end town, and a boring place to live. A number of the students talk on camera about how much they want to be in the band, and how much it will mean to them, seeing it as a massive opportunity. Many are what would be regarded as ‘problem’ students, some who have been excluded from other schools, others who get into trouble, essentially many of the young people picked appear to be those who are having trouble connecting with conventional schooling and it is pretty heartening to see young people who have earlier said that they really don’t see any point to school really inspired to work at something. Simmons is not getting everything his own way though. There was a bit of drama in the first show in that Chris, who Gene obviously thinks is the ideal front man for the band, and someone with real talent, is taken off on a weeks holiday by his parents. Gene goes so far as to try and persuade his parents not to take him away, but to no avail – so the band line-up is picked without him – a source of more drama to come methinks.

In amongst the music there were some amusing Gene moments too. First off his chauffeur is technically a bigger British pop star than Simmons, in that he was in a band that had a number one hit back in the 80’s – Kiss has never had a number one in the UK. His chauffeur also takes him on a tour of the hotspots of Lowestoft, meeting some OAP’s who actually recongnise him from the TV, and a couple having their ‘Tuesday outing’ down to the pier. It has to be said that Simmons is less than impressed, indeed he forgets where he actually is at times. However, again Simmons initial training as a teacher again does show, that despite the act, he actually is very good at connecting with the young people. He also seems to have learned from some of the problems with the previous class, in that he hasn’t fixed on a particular band lineup – trying to avoid the problems last time when half the group almost totally switched off when they weren’t picked. Certainly it seems that the new series will be just as interesting as the last.

Having said that, there is an interesting little gem revealed by the Radio Times. Whilst it goes totally unmentioned in the series, the school already has a bit of a rock heritage, with a new music suite opened in 2004 by the Darkness, three of whom are former pupils.

Work on the Organ Begins

Dismantling the Organ

If you’ve visited St James in recent months you are sure to have either spotted the Organ Pipe in the porch, or had a brochure shoved into your hand, all related to our appeal to have our organ restored. Well, as of yesterday, the workmen finally arrived to start the job, by taking the whole thing to bits, and moving it to a workshop in Kent, where it will all be rebuilt, repaired and in certain areas modernised. Of course then they’ll take it all to bits again, and put it back in St James, hopefully just in time for Easter!

There wasn’t much to see at the pipe end of things, but when I stopped by the Church for a look, work was beginning on taking the console apart. Now it has to be said that various organists have said various things about this console at times – some suggesting either a bonfire, or use of an axe, but apparently the console is going to be restored too! However the key difference will be in what is going to be modernised, the electrics.

The organ was put into the Church in 1936 (in fact the last person who referred to it as the ‘New Organ’ has only died within the past couple of years) to replace a small chamber organ in the north aisle, and was built by the Compton Organ Company – better known for their cinema organs, including the organ at the Odeon Leicester Square. You can read a history of the company here. As with the cinema organs, our Compton is what is termed an Extension Organ, where maximum use is made of the minimum number of pipes by reusing the same pipes for different stops on the organ console. This meant that St James could fit a reasonably versatile instrument into a pretty small church, and to be frank it is the only option for a real pipe organ in the building. In order to get all this pipe reuse working, the only option was electric action, so the bit that is getting modernised is the bit that has been causing the problems, the 1930’s original switches, circuits and wires. These are in such a state that when the initial survey of the organ was carried out prior to this work there was concern about moving the wires in case some of them broke. Looking into the back of the console as it was dismantled there is a warning in red pen written on a label inside, fairly obviously from later than the 1930’s warning of the danger of electric shocks from the wires in the back – something like this would never get past health and safety today!

What we’re looking forward to later in the year is that with the modern electronics, we’ll actually be able to get a mobile(ish) organ console. Whilst currently we were afraid to move anything, the new wiring will have two different points where we can plug the console into the organ, allowing the organist to be better located whether the choir is singing from the front for Matins, Evensong and the like, or the north aisle for services that need the altar rail.

Anyway, I’ll be sure to take another picture of the finished article in a few months time.