Tag Archives: Episcopal Church

Finally Some Division Interrupts the Sunbathing at the Primates Conference

Until last night, for members of the press, the Primates Meeting in Tanzania has been a somewhat boring affair. Firstly, the meeting itself has been kept carefully separate, so effectively the media have just had to sit around by the pool and gossip. Such is the flakiness of the internet connection, that in fact Ruth Gledhill who has stayed in London is able to produce just as complete reports as Stephen Bates. Largely it seems that those over there have been left with nothing much to do but sit by the pool sunbathing.

The reason the press has been so bored, is that up until now, events have not gone according to the script. First off, thanks it seems to a bit of strong leadership from the Archbishop of Canterbury, Bishop Jefferts Schori, and the Archbishop of York John Sentamu (invited by Rowan Williams to represent the Church of England allowing him to focus on chairing the meeting) were allowed to stay, and other primates didn’t leave. Yet again it seems that it is an example of how in this whole sorry affair, people are happy to try and boot another group out, but won’t leave themselves.

Following that, the report that was widely expected to back the conservative line that the Episcopal Church was ‘in breach’ of the Windsor report, actually came out and said that they were pretty much in line – more than that it criticised the anti-Windsor actions of people like Archbishop Akinola who have been setting up Churches in the US, as reported by Stephen Bates. Having said that this did produce some reaction – but again this was on the web, not from the conference centre.

There was a bit of excitement yesterday, when Archbishop Akinola, returning from a meeting outside the primates part of the conference centre got spotted and cornered by the press – although he was less than talkative…

However, the press got a little bit of division last night, when seven of the primates failed to attend the communion service – although it should be noted that this was half as many as failed to attend at the previous meeting two years ago. This does seem to be the first bit of real division that has occurred amongst the primates. Giles Fraser predicted the tactic:

Especially keep in mind the first principle of effective warfare: take their strength, and turn it into a weakness. Make them feel they are fighting for the truth of the gospel. Make them feel that everything hangs on it; that it’s all down to them. That way, they will be able to justify any behaviour — cruelty, bullying, division — and eventually the whole thing will collapse in bitterness and recrimination. Allow them to do our work for us. The fact that they won’t take communion together is a cracking start.

Alongside this, last Sunday Ruth Gledhill compared this sort of behaviour to what happens to her five year old son.

Putting it in to context, in the Guardian today, Giles Fraser also highlights quite how much this high level Church politics and globe trotting really matters:

For the communion allows bishops of crisis-stricken dioceses to get on a plane and reinvent themselves as players on the world stage. Many parishes see less and less of their bishops as they clock up the air miles.

In the traditional Church of England, the parish is the unit that matters to most worshippers. And at the level of the parish, the crisis in global Anglicanism is irrelevant. While bishops and archbishops squabble and plot, the local church gets on with saying its prayers and caring for the needy. These faithful are now being badly let down by their leadership.

So what will be the outcome? I really don’t know, but I’m half expecting a compromise to be reached. Look at what’s happened. In terms of the conference, aside from the publicity stunt last night, there have been none of the predicted walk-outs, and as Giles Fraser has pointed out, how relevant will whatever happens be to the people on the ground anyway? Thankfully Dave Walker (sadly another person who couldn’t find a news organisation or Church expense account to fund a week in the sun) is on hand to put it all into context.

Archbishop Akinola avoids the press and The White Sands originally uploaded by scottgunn.

Anglican or Anglican’t

This week, Dave over at Cartoon Church recommended a video blog called Father Matthew Presents which seems to have been getting a bit of coverage across the pond. Certainly what he is doing is a bit different from the usual video-tape of a sermon that I’ve seen elsewhere.

The blogger in question is a curate, currently serving at St Paul’s Episcopal Church in Yonkers, New York. Reading some of the background, as a church they have been through difficult times, ultimately closing a couple of years ago. However, the church has been re-planted, in that they have started again in the existing building, trying to grow a new congregation. As part of that, Father Matthew has been producing a regular video blog, which can be found on YouTube.

As with any other blog, some of the topics are pretty light-hearted, so for example this posting explains how much he loves his job because the building includes a Carillon allowing him to play classic video game theme tunes to anyone who is listening… Alongside this there are items explaining aspects of the gospels – take this posting about Mary Magdalene. He also does a nice line in explaining the complications of the Episcopal/Anglican Church including a Scripture, Tradition and Reason Puppet Show, and the Episcopal position on Diversity in Faith with juggling. He even gets onto the challenges facing the modern Church, including the frustration that they never taught him about marketing in seminary!

Perhaps our favourite so far, is an insight into the task of writing a sermon… Beth particularly liked hour 4. 😀

Anyway, I’ve added Father Matthew to my subscriptions in using the handy YouTube RSS Feed function, and am looking forward to see what he comes up with in the future.

Happy Lawyers in Virginia, Unhappy Covenanters in the UK

If you’re a lawyer in Virginia, you must be rubbing your hands with glee at the prospect of the millions of dollars worth of fees that you’re going to clock up now that the parishes of Truro and Falls Church have voted to join the Nigerian Church mission in the US. The key point being that in addition to voting to leave, they also voted to try and take all the property of the parish with them, worth an estimated $25,000,000. Needless to say the Diocese are insisting that the property belongs to the Episcopal Church as a whole, not to the particular congregations – hence if necessary, and it looks like it will be, they will be calling in the lawyers to evict the group from their former Church.

Ekklesia carries a report on the vote, including the figures in favour of the split, which also highlights the difficulty the new missionary Bishop Martyn Minns (and rector of Truro) is having already with some of the things that Archbishop Akinola of Nigeria has said, and continues to say. Indeed, listening to the interview with Minns this morning on the Today programme, he is questioned on, and disassociates himself with the language of some of Akinola’s statements. Interestingly he also declares the looming argument over property as silly, and says that he only wants to get on with the business of being a Church. Sadly I suspect that what with the impending messy property battle, and the probably open season on the Churches the next time Akinola makes a statement, that may well be what he has little time to do.

Ruth Gledhill discusses the story on her blog and Stephen Bates reports on the story for the Guardian, Ruth also highlighting the cost of the impending property battle, and Stephen giving some more detail on why these particular parishes are important. Interestingly, Stephen also refers to the proposed ‘covenant’ which I mentioned last week, particularly the Bishop of Durham’s reply. On the same subject Dave over at Cartoon Church has come up with a particularly cutting cartoon, which I found particularly funny, but I suspect a number of people involved in the ‘covenant’ probably won’t… Having said that, with the numbers of significant people in the various organisations the ‘covenant’ claimed to represent publicly distancing themselves from the whole episode I’m quite sure that they’ve managed to do their position a good deal of damage by the whole episode.

Yet More Anglican Postings

Father Jake has posted a series of interesting posts over the past few days. The Bishop of New Hampshire has written an open letter in the wake of B033, especially with regards to the feelings of delegates who felt they were betraying other members of the Church in the cause of Anglican unity, only to have it thrown back in their faces. The Times has published an article questioning whether Rowan Williams is too brainy to lead the Church. Perhaps the most interesting comment item is this article from the Guardian comparing and commending the US Church, and comparing it with what is happening in the Church of England. Michael Hampson, the author of the article has a new book, The Last Rites: The End of the Church of England that will be published in October.

Guardian Interview with Jefferts Schori

Yesterdays Guardian had an interview with Bishop Jefferts Schori that is worth reading. The image you get is someone who is generally frustrated at the church being diverted from it’s true mission, much as I mentioned a few days ago. Take the following extract as an example:

And no pushover either. Asked at an initial press conference a pointed question by a British conservative evangelical lobbyist about what third-world Anglican women would make of her views on homosexuality, she shot back: “I should think they would be more interested in issues of hunger, clean water supply and education for their children.�